# Car Insurance Tracking: 5 Risk Tiers vs. 40% Premium Swings

Amelia Palmer · November 14, 2026

> Telematics sorts drivers into 5 risk tiers, swinging premiums by 40%. A two-week braking and mileage audit shows if you should switch or stay static.

Telematics-based car insurance in 2026 sorts drivers into five risk tiers, with behavior scores swinging premiums by up to 40% in either direction.

This outcome depends on a two-week self-audit of your braking and mileage confirming you rank in the top two tiers; drivers in tier 3 or below should remain on a static policy.

![Telematics-based car insurance in 2026 sorts drivers into — Car Insurance Tracking](https://static.mm-ais.com/article-images-ai/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-4-ai-b8a76922.jpg)

## How Telematics Sorts You Into Tiers

In 2026, most telematics programs place each driver into one of roughly five risk tiers, and the tier is set by an underwriting score built from telematics data — not by which app brand you enroll in. The Resolute Dynamics fleet model describes the mechanism: each driver is scored on driver performance metrics, underwriters use those metrics to assign a risk level, and a consistent pattern of safe driving leads to lower premiums while risky habits trigger higher insurance costs. That five-tier sort is the gate every program runs before it quotes you anything.

Four behaviors feed the score. Resolute Dynamics (December 2025) names sudden braking, sharp acceleration, hard cornering, and tailgating as the red flags that raise the likelihood of collisions and vehicle wear. Each event is logged and folded into the driver performance score, so the tier reflects how you drive — not your age, your vehicle, or the insurer's logo on the dashboard.

Usage is scored as a separate input from behavior. The same model treats high mileage, operation on rough terrain, and long idling periods as their own risk signals. The practical consequence: a driver with a clean behavior record who clocks heavy mileage or idles for long stretches can still be down-tiered. Behavior and usage are combined before the tier is assigned, and either input alone can move you.

| Score input | What it captures |
| --- | --- |
| Driver performance metrics | Sudden braking, sharp acceleration, hard cornering, tailgating |
| Vehicle usage patterns | High mileage, rough terrain, long idling |

Root's model flips the traditional order of underwriting. Instead of leaning on past claims, vehicle type, and driver age, it collects driving behavior through a smartphone app and scores the driver directly, as The Motley Fool has noted. Resolute Dynamics frames the same shift industry-wide: insurers no longer rely solely on historical claims or broad risk categories. The tier comes first; the premium follows from it.

What that means for you: run a two-week self-audit of your own braking and mileage before enrolling anywhere. If your self-scored tier lands in the top two, a telematics program is worth the data you hand over. If it lands at tier 3 or below, stay on a static policy — the sort will price your behavior against you, and no app brand changes that outcome.

![How Telematics Sorts You Into Tiers — Car Insurance Tracking](https://static.mm-ais.com/article-images-pixabay/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-4-64431bff.jpg)

## The Evidence: What Telematics Actually Moves

Independent sources converge on two findings that matter before you enroll in a telematics program: usage-based data can make underwriting more precise, and the widely advertised savings ceiling sits at 40%. That ceiling, however, is a boundary condition rather than a typical outcome, and improved accuracy does not eliminate every pricing gap. Reading these claims together gives you a realistic baseline for judging whether a two-week self-audit is likely to work in your favor.

| Source | What the source reports | What it means for a prospective enrollee |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 24autoinsurance.website | Advertises savings of up to 40% when comparing cheap car insurance rates. | The 40% figure is an advertised maximum, not a median; treat it as a best-case ceiling, not an expected result. |
| SambaSafety | Reports that telematics in commercial auto improves underwriting and risk assessment but “cannot solve all the complexities and nuances of premium leakage.” | Telematics sharpens pricing inputs, yet the improvement is partial and does not guarantee a perfectly matched premium. |
| FasterCapital | States that telematics has transformed underwriting by offering “a more accurate, personalized” way to assess risk. | Pricing becomes more individualized, so your own recorded driving pattern carries more weight in the outcome. |

The 40% figure from 24autoinsurance.website is useful as a headline marker, but only if you read it correctly. An advertised maximum describes the outer edge of possible savings, not the experience of a typical driver. When you evaluate a telematics offer, compare any projected discount against that ceiling and ask whether the quote reflects a guaranteed rate, an introductory estimate, or a range that can change after monitoring.

SambaSafety and FasterCapital point in the same direction from different angles. FasterCapital attributes the shift to more accurate, personalized risk assessment, while SambaSafety confirms that telematics improves underwriting and risk assessment in commercial auto but cannot resolve every complexity and nuance of premium leakage. Taken together, the evidence supports a clear rule: telematics can refine how risk is priced, but it does not remove uncertainty from the final premium.

![The Evidence: What Telematics Actually Moves — Car Insurance Tracking](https://static.mm-ais.com/article-images-pixabay/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-4-d2839449.jpg)

## Five Programs Compared: Who Wins Where

Program choice should follow the pricing trigger, not the app logo. Root wins when a driver's self-audit already shows top-tier habits because it can quote from behavior before binding; it loses appeal when the first policy period includes a relocation or new commute that changes the data. Traditional carriers with UBI add-ons adjust an existing static policy rather than replacing the rating base. Maryland is the outlier: Senate Bill 984, as Beinsure reports, would bar insurers from using telematics data to set premiums for the vehicle it was collected from and would block cancellation or nonrenewal based on that data.

| Program or rule | Where it wins | Where it can backfire |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Root — winner for clean pre-bind scores | Drivers whose self-audit shows top-tier habits | Drivers whose early policy period includes a relocation or new commute |
| Traditional carrier with UBI add-on | Drivers who want behavior data to adjust an existing static policy | Drivers expecting a full reprice from telematics alone |
| Maryland Senate Bill 984 (Beinsure) | Drivers seeking limits on telematics-based premium setting and nonrenewal | Drivers expecting telematics discounts to flow through normally |

Root's pre-bind model makes the self-audit the gate. A clean pre-bind score can reward habits you already control, but the same model can treat an early move or commute change as a new risk profile rather than a temporary disruption. That is why the win is conditional on stability as much as on skill.

For traditional carriers, the UBI layer is an adjustment, not a reset. Behavior data can move the premium within the existing policy, but it does not remove the underlying static factors that set the base. Drivers who want a full behavior-based price should not assume an add-on will deliver the same result as a quote built from telematics.

In Maryland, the calculus changes before any score is compared. If SB 984's limits apply, telematics data cannot be used to price the vehicle it came from and cannot support cancellation or nonrenewal. That constrains both the discount path and the penalty path, so Maryland drivers should verify the current rule before treating any program like a standard telematics discount.

The practical check is simple: match your self-audit result to the pricing architecture. Top-tier habits point toward a pre-bind behavior quote; a mid-tier or lower result points toward staying on a static policy or using an add-on that cannot fully reprice you; in Maryland, confirm whether SB 984 is in force before assuming either path will work like a normal telematics program.

![Five Programs Compared: Who Wins Where — Car Insurance Tracking](https://static.mm-ais.com/article-images-pixabay/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-4-7e36f5ca.jpg)

## The Numbers That Decide Your Tier

Braking behavior is one of the red-flag metrics Resolute Dynamics (December 2025) names for telematics underwriting, alongside sharp acceleration, hard cornering, and tailgating. To gauge where you stand, open your app’s trip log and count braking events per trip rather than per week; weekly totals rise and fall with how much you drive and can mask your true pattern. Normalize the data by dividing your total flagged braking events by the total miles driven during your two-week self-audit, then multiply by 100 to get braking events per 100 miles. Record this figure alongside your carrier’s published scoring criteria — each insurer sets its own thresholds, so the carrier’s disclosures, not a generic benchmark, are the only reliable comparison point.

Mileage is the second controllable input. Resolute Dynamics treats high mileage as its own usage-based risk signal, separate from driving behavior. Pull your odometer readings or trip-distance totals from the app for the audit period, add them together, and annualize the result by multiplying your two-week mileage by 26. Compare that annualized figure against the mileage band breakpoints listed in the carrier’s rate filing or program disclosures, not against a generic assumption about what counts as “low” mileage. Because each insurer sets its own cutoffs, the filing is the only reliable benchmark for your self-score.

Time-of-day exposure completes the picture. Whether higher-risk hours affect your score depends on the specific program, so check your carrier’s telematics documentation before assuming it does. Export or review your trip timestamps and calculate the share of your trips or miles that occur during any higher-risk windows the carrier defines. If the app labels trips by time-of-day risk, use those labels directly; if it does not, tally the trips yourself against the carrier’s stated windows so your self-audit reflects the same inputs the underwriter will use.

After two weeks, combine these three readings—braking events per 100 miles, annualized mileage band, and time-of-day exposure share—and compare them to the carrier’s published tier criteria. If your self-scored profile aligns with the top two tiers, enrolling in a telematics program is a reasonable next step; if it aligns with tier 3 or below, staying on a static policy is the safer choice. Treat this audit as a check against your current annual premium, because the same controllable inputs that place you in a tier are what determine whether your rate moves up or down.

![The Numbers That Decide Your Tier — Car Insurance Tracking](https://static.mm-ais.com/article-images-pixabay/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-4-223a1f5f.jpg)

## What the 40% Claim Does Not Prove

The widely advertised 40% premium swing is a comparison ceiling across carriers, not a discount you can attribute entirely to a telematics score. Marketing materials, such as those from 24autoinsurance.website, promote savings of up to 40%, but that figure often blends behavior-based adjustments with the gains of shopping for a new policy. Before you treat the ceiling as a guaranteed reward for careful driving, separate the carrier-switching discount from any change tied to your own driving data.

Data quality can also distort where a program places you. SambaSafety notes that telematics cannot solve all the complexities and nuances of premium leakage, which means the data a carrier collects may not capture your driving fully or accurately. Treat a single month of poor results as a signal to investigate sensor placement, phone permissions, or trip misclassification — not as definitive proof that you belong in a lower tier.

The table below separates the edge cases in which the tier rule breaks from the conditions under which it still offers a useful enrollment check.

| Edge case | When the tier rule breaks | When it still wins |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Maryland-style bans | If enacted, Maryland Senate Bill 984 would bar insurers from using telematics data to set premiums for the vehicle it was collected from or to cancel, nonrenew, or refuse to underwrite a policy based on that data (beinsure.com), severing the link between your score and your rate. | In states without such restrictions, collected driving data can still inform the premium for the enrolled vehicle, making a self-audit relevant. |
| Premium leakage limits | Telematics cannot resolve every complexity of premium leakage, so underwriting and risk-assessment improvements may not translate into a proportional rate change for every driver (SambaSafety). | When a carrier’s pricing model directly incorporates verified driving inputs, consistent behavior can still produce a measurable adjustment. |
| Data-quality failures | Incomplete or weak data sources can mis-tier a good driver, making a short-term score an unreliable basis for switching or staying. | When your two-week self-audit aligns with complete, accurately captured trips, the resulting tier is a stronger predictor of program fit. |

Use these limits as a pre-enrollment filter: confirm that your state permits telematics-based pricing for your vehicle, verify that your tracking data is complete, and compare any quoted behavior discount against the full offer. If your self-audit places you in tier 3 or below—or if any of these edge cases apply—remaining on a static policy is the lower-risk choice.

![What the 40% Claim Does Not Prove — Car Insurance Tracking](https://static.mm-ais.com/article-images-pixabay/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-4-b1790065.jpg)

## Two Weeks, One Decision

Before you enroll in a telematics program in 2026, run a two-week self-audit using the same driving app or vehicle log you plan to share with a carrier. Log your miles, hard-braking events, and trip timestamps, then score yourself against the carrier’s published criteria. Treat the result as a working hypothesis, not a guarantee: the goal of the next 14 days is to confirm that your everyday habits consistently support the placement you expect, since no self-audit can replicate the carrier’s own scoring.

Use three checkpoints to make the enrollment decision. Checkpoint 1 is your week-1 braking rate: record total miles and hard-braking events, then calculate events per 100 miles. Checkpoint 2 is your week-2 braking rate after a route or timing change designed to reduce sudden stops; compare it directly with week 1 to confirm the behavior is stable, not a one-off. Checkpoint 3 is your annualized mileage versus the carrier’s mileage band: project your current driving over 12 months and verify it still aligns with the band you expect to report. If all three checkpoints hold, you have evidence to enroll; if any one slips, pause and extend the audit.

Translate the decision into dollars before you commit. On a $1,665 base premium, the advertised 40% ceiling represents a swing of up to $666 per year in either direction. For planning, however, treat 10–15%—about $165 to $250 annually—as the realistic range to budget around, since individual outcomes vary by carrier and measured behavior.

The cost of being wrong cuts both ways. Enrolling when your true driving pattern falls at tier 3 or below can expose you to a surcharge approaching that $666 ceiling, turning a monitoring trial into a costly mistake. Staying on a static policy when your self-audit reliably confirms a top-two tier means forgoing roughly $165 to $250 in realistic yearly savings. The two-week audit is a small time investment that clarifies which side of that trade-off you are likely to land on.

## Worked Example: Run the Numbers

Illustration only: Party is Driver A, a single driver whose two-week self-audit places them in tier 2 of the roughly five risk tiers. Scenario is a 12-month personal auto policy with an illustrative term start of January 1, 2026. For arithmetic only, normalize the static premium to 100 premium units; this is not a quoted price. The grounded outer bound used here is a telematics swing of up to 40% in either direction.

| Step | Calculation | Result |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1. Static term cost | 100 units | 100 units |
| 2. Telematics at -40% | 100 × (1 − 0.40) | 60 units |
| 3. Discount value | 100 − 60 | 40 units (40%) |
| 4. Telematics at +40% | 100 × (1 + 0.40) | 140 units |
| 5. Surcharge value | 140 − 100 | 40 units (40%) |

Step 1 sets the baseline: the static policy costs 100 units for the term. Step 2 applies the maximum illustrative discount available at the grounded 40% ceiling, giving 60 units. Step 3 shows the gain is 40 units, or 40% of the static baseline. Step 4 shows the downside if the score instead earns the maximum surcharge: 140 units. Step 5 shows that downside is also 40 units.

For this illustration, telematics wins when the realized adjustment is a discount, because any result below 100 units beats the static baseline; it loses when the result is a surcharge above 100 units. The break-even trigger is a realized adjustment of exactly 0%, or 100 units: at that point the two options cost the same, and any worse telematics result favors staying on the static policy.

Because the 40% figure is a ceiling and not a promise, treat the 60-unit result as an outer bound. Re-run the same arithmetic with your own realized discount or surcharge before enrolling; if your self-scored tier is 3 or below, the static policy remains the safer default.

## If/Then Rules for Enrolling in 2026

Use a two-week self-audit as a hard gate before you share driving data with any insurer. During that window, log your trips with your phone or vehicle’s built-in tools and score yourself against the same controllable inputs that matter most: hard braking frequency, mileage, and time-of-day exposure. The four rules below translate that self-audit into a clear enrollment decision in 2026.

**Rule 1 — Enroll when your baseline is clean.** IF your two-week self-audit shows a low braking rate per 100 miles and minimal high-risk-hour exposure by the carrier’s own published criteria, THEN enroll. A clean baseline is the most reliable signal that opting in will work in your favor, because the outcome is driven by your recorded behavior rather than the app brand. Verify your numbers against the carrier’s scoring disclosures before deciding, since each program sets its own thresholds.

**Rule 2 — In Maryland, verify the law before you share data.** IF you drive in Maryland, THEN track the status of Senate Bill 984 before enrolling. According to BeInsure, SB 984 would bar insurers from using telematics data to determine premiums for the vehicle from which it was collected and would also restrict related underwriting actions. That potential change alters the risk-benefit calculation of sharing your data, so confirm current rules with the state legislature or your insurer before you opt in.

**Rule 3 — Stay static when your audit is borderline or worse.** IF your self-audit lands at tier 3 or below, THEN remain on a static policy instead of enrolling. Sharing data that reflects frequent hard stops, high exposure, or late-night driving can work against you, so avoid locking in a telematics record until your habits produce a stronger baseline.

**Rule 4 — Re-test on a fixed cadence after making changes.** IF you stay on a static policy, THEN run a new two-week self-audit after six months of deliberate route or schedule changes. Use the same checks each time—hard brakes per 100 miles, total mileage, and late-night trips—to determine whether you now meet the Rule 1 threshold. Treat this cadence as an ongoing decision loop: enroll only when your own data confirms you belong in the top tiers, and reassess periodically as your driving patterns evolve.

## What to do next

| Step | Action | Why it matters |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Begin a 14-day self-audit by manually logging your hard braking frequency, total mileage, and time-of-day exposure. | These controllable inputs—not the telematics app brand—determine where you fall within the 5 risk tiers used in 2026 behavior-based car insurance programs. |
| 2 | Score your driving behavior against the 5 risk tiers to estimate your likely placement. | Your behavior score directly drives the potential 40% premium swing, so an honest self-assessment predicts whether telematics will help or hurt your rate. |
| 3 | If your self-audit places you in the top two tiers, request telematics program details from your current insurer and compare them against your static policy. | Drivers in the top tiers are best positioned to benefit from behavior-based pricing over a standard 12 months policy term. |
| 4 | If your self-scored tier is 3 or below, stay on a static policy and do not enroll in a telematics program. | Avoiding enrollment protects you from a potential premium increase tied to the 40% behavior-score swing. |
| 5 | Set a reminder to repeat your 14-day self-audit in 6 months if you scored tier 3 or below. | Re-testing after improving hard braking, mileage, or time-of-day exposure lets you reassess whether you have moved into the top two tiers before enrolling. |

## Frequently Asked Questions

**What self-audit is required before the premium swing applies?**

This outcome depends on a two-week self-audit of your braking and mileage confirming you rank in the top two tiers.

**Which drivers should stay on a static policy?**

Drivers in tier 3 or below should remain on a static policy.

**What four behaviors feed the telematics score?**

Sudden braking, sharp acceleration, hard cornering, and tailgating are the red flags that raise the likelihood of collisions and vehicle wear.

**Does the tier reflect age, vehicle, or insurer brand?**

The tier reflects how you drive, not your age, your vehicle, or the insurer's logo on the dashboard.

**Is usage scored separately from behavior?**

Usage is scored as a separate input from behavior.

**What happens before any quote is issued?**

That five-tier sort is the gate every program runs before it quotes you anything.

## Quick answers

| What does telematics-based car insurance do in the 2026 figure? | It sorts drivers into five risk tiers, with behavior scores swinging premiums by up to the 40% figure in either direction. |
| --- | --- |
| What confirms that you rank in the top two tiers? | The 14-day figure self-audit of your braking and mileage confirms you rank in the top two tiers. |
| What should drivers in tier 3 or below do? | Drivers in tier 3 or below should remain on a static policy. |
| What sets the risk tier? | The tier is set by an underwriting score built from telematics data, not by which app brand you enroll in. |
| What four behaviors are named as red flags? | Sudden braking, sharp acceleration, hard cornering, and tailgating are named as red flags that raise the likelihood of collisions and vehicle wear. |

Also worth reading: **How the EU AI Act's August 2, 2026 high-risk deadline for life and health insurance underwriting changes Article 86 explanation requests — and the six-month Article 26 log retention rule insurers must meet for automated pricing decisions**: [How the EU AI Act's](https://in-surely.com/blog/how-the-eu-ai-acts-august-2-2026-high-risk-deadline-for-life-and-health-insurance-underwriting-changes-article-86-explanation-requests-and-the-six-month-article-26-log-retention-rule-insurers-must-mee.php) · **Product liability insurance: What it covers and who needs it**: [Product liability insurance: What it](https://in-surely.com/blog/product_liability_insurance_what_it_covers_and_who_needs_it.php) · **how to get renters insurance for apartment**: [how to get renters insurance](https://in-surely.com/blog/how-to-get-renters-insurance-for-apartment.php)

### Related reading

- [How GEICO's 16-Digit Claims Tracking System Streamlines Insurance Claims Processing in 2024](https://in-surely.com/blog/how_geico_s_16_digit_claims_tracking_system_streamlines_insu.php)
- [How Small Businesses Can Reduce Commercial Vehicle Insurance Premiums Through GPS Fleet Tracking Data in 2024](https://in-surely.com/blog/how_small_businesses_can_reduce_commercial_vehicle_insurance.php)
- [New York car insurance savings: usage-based telematics saves 20% or keeps full premium](https://in-surely.com/blog/new-york-car-insurance-savings-usage-based-telematics-saves-20-or-keeps-full-premium.php)
- [Understanding Life Insurance Policy Fees 7 Hidden Charges That Impact Your Premium in 2024](https://in-surely.com/blog/understanding_life_insurance_policy_fees_7_hidden_charges_th.php)
- [How Insurance Payment Calculators Can Underestimate Your Premium by 23% A Data Analysis](https://in-surely.com/blog/how_insurance_payment_calculators_can_underestimate_your_pre.php)
- [New Study Shows 7 Key Factors Driving Commercial Liability Insurance Premium Increases in 2024](https://in-surely.com/blog/new_study_shows_7_key_factors_driving_commercial_liability_i.php)

### Latest

- [How to verify Nacha WEB return codes and fee liability before ACH pulls](https://in-surely.com/blog/how-to-verify-nacha-web-return-codes-and-fee-liability-before-ach-pulls.php)
- [Telematics rate hike complaints: 2023 AI Bulletin, shield or no shield](https://in-surely.com/blog/telematics-rate-hike-complaints-2023-ai-bulletin-shield-or-no-shield.php)
- [AI Transparency and Usage-Based Insurance Opt-In Rates: A Verify-First Guide](https://in-surely.com/blog/ai-transparency-and-usage-based-insurance-opt-in-rates-a-verify-first-guide.php)

Canonical: https://in-surely.com/blog/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-40-premium-swings.php
Markdown: https://in-surely.com/blog/car-insurance-tracking-5-risk-tiers-vs-40-premium-swings.php/index.md
